It's a Setup

When I taught I tried to instill the concept that you should be able to pass an exam without a single correct numerical answer, because the problem set-up was the most important part of the solution. Few of my students believed me, but I see that my experience was not unique. The First Excited State has Missing the Important Stuff, which sets up a response at Uncertain Principles, The Process Is as Important as the Answer

Chad points to the problem of giving a problem with only algebraic expressions

The problem with this method, of course, is that students hate it with the burning passion of a million white-hot suns. If you think they get unhappy when they don’t have the exact numerical answers to work toward, just wait until you see their reaction to no numbers at all.

One thought on “It's a Setup

  1. Wrong audience! Managerial folk are driven by process, technical folk are driven by product. You would field no objections if the audience carried casebooks rather than textbooks. Which population cares about significant figures?

Comments are closed.